The Realist Illusion About Russia and Ukraine: A Response to Stephen Walt

What really causes the “Ukraine crises”

27 January 2022

Aliaksei Kazharski

Visegrad Insight Fellow

Realists claim that strategic competition of great powers is a given, an inevitable reality, but history has already proven them wrong.

Stephen Walt blames the new “Ukraine crisis” on the “liberal illusions” that pushed for NATO enlargement, making Russia feel threatened. He claims that agreeing on Ukraine’s neutral status will make it safer for everyone, including the Ukrainians. However, his argument is built on the dangerous illusion that Moscow is a rational actor that is driven by tangible security concerns. In truth, there is no serious grounds for such concerns and the authoritarian regime in Russia is not bound by that logic. It constructs international threats randomly because that helps regime survival.

Editor’s Pick: Escaping Great Power Politics

It seems to become a bit of a tradition that every time Russia attacks (or threatens to attack) Ukraine, a renowned American IR realist comes forward to explain why this is the West’s fault. In 2014, it was John Mearsheimer with his famous op-ed. Now, it’s Stephen Walt presenting in his article for Foreign Policy “Liberal Illusions Caused the Ukraine Crisis” what looks like a very similar argument. NATO enlargement was a mistake because it endangered Russia, and Moscow has no choice but to react.

Subscribe

Democratic security comes at a price. What is yours? By subscribing or donating now gain access to analysis, forecasts and scenarios by leading analysts and reporters who monitor democratic risks and develop policy debate from Central Europe on Central Europe.

MonthlyVAT included

€4/month

See all details

  • Full access to articles and reports
  • Monthly foresights and risk analysis delivered by e-mail
  • Weekly newsletter with most important highlights
  • Visegrad Insight social media community groups invitation

AnnualVAT included

€40/year

See all details

  • All monthly features PLUS…
  • Free invitation to one editorial board discussion to participate in deciding on the future direction of the Visegrad Insight
  • Free delivery of two select hardcopies of Visegrad Insight reports

Student OR Donation

Choose your contribution

See all details

  • Full access to articles and reports
  • Monthly foresights, weekly newsletters, and risk analysis delivered by e-mail
  • Free invitation to one editorial board discussion to participate in deciding on the future direction of the Visegrad Insight (annual subscription only)

Can I receive an invoice?

Yes. You will receive a receipt immediately after purchase and a VAT invoice upon request. The subscription amount includes tax. In case of a donation, there is no tax.

Are my credit card details safe?

Yes. The payment is processed by STRIPE www.stripe.com entrusted also by Amazon, Zoom, Booking.com and used by other global NGOs and businesses in the world. We do not store your credit card details.

How modify or cancel my subscription?

At any moment you can manage your subscription and account details. Sign in to modify or cancel.

Aliaksei Kazharski

Visegrad Insight Fellow

Visegrad Insight Fellow. Researcher at the Institute of European Studies and International Relations of the Comenius University in Bratislava and a lecturer at the Department of Security Studies of Charles University in Prague

Newsletter

Weekly updates with our latest articles and the editorial commentary.